Skip to main content

Table 3 Characteristics of eligible studies reported on sources of milk contamination

From: Prevalence and molecular characteristics of Staphylococcus aureus in raw milk and milk products in Ethiopia: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Study

Study year

Region

Study area

Sample type

N

n (%)

(Wodaje and Beyene 2021)

2015/2016

Oromia

Mojo

Milker hand swab

15

3(20)

(Wodaje and Beyene 2021)

2015/2016

Oromia

Mojo

Milking bucket swab

15

1(6.7)

(Wodaje and Beyene 2021)

2015/2016

Oromia

Mojo

Bulk tank swab

15

2(13.3)

(Kalayu et al. 2020)

2014/15

Tigray

Mekelle

Nasal swab

71

22(31)

(Regasa et al. 2019)

2017/18

Oromia

Mukaturi & Sululta

Milking bucket swab

30

6(20)

(Regasa et al. 2019)

2017/18

Oromia

Mukaturi & Sululta

Milker hand swab

24

6(25)

(Regasa et al. 2019)

2017/18

Oromia

Mukaturi & Sululta

Towel swab

10

1(10)

(Tsige 2018)

2017/18

Oromia

Arsi Negelle

Milker hand swab

35

12(34.3)

(Tsige 2018)

2017/18

Oromia

Arsi Negelle

MCC Container swab

21

5(23.8)

(Ayele et al. 2017)

2014/15

Oromia

Sebeta

Milking bucket swab

27

3(11.1)

(Ayele et al. 2017)

2014/15

Oromia

Sebeta

Milker hand swab

25

8(32)

(Abunna et al. 2017)

2014/15

Oromia

Sebeta

Bulk tank swab

10

2(20)

(Abunna et al. 2017)

2014/15

Oromia

Sebeta

Milking bucket swab

10

2(20)

(Abunna et al. 2017)

2014/15

Oromia

Sebeta

Milker hand swab

10

1(10)

(Beyene et al. 2017)

2013/14

Addis Ababa

Addis Ababa

Milking bucket swab

8

2(25)

(Beyene et al. 2017)

2013/14

Addis Ababa

Addis Ababa

Milker hand swab

8

2(25)

(Beyene et al. 2017)

2013/14

Addis Ababa

Addis Ababa

Bulk tank swab

8

1(12.5)

(Amenu et al. 2016)

2015

SNNPR

Hawassa

Water for cleaning

79

31(39.2)

(Abunna et al. 2017)

2014

Oromia

Asella

Bulk tank swab

9

3(33.3)

(Abunna et al. 2017)

2014

Oromia

Asella

Milker hand swab

9

1(11.1)

(Abunna et al. 2017)

2014

Oromia

Asella

Nasal swab

9

3(33.3)

(Megersa 2015)

2014/15

Oromia

Ambo and Guder

Milking bucket swab

44

4(9)

(Megersa 2015)

2014/15

Oromia

Ambo and Guder

Milker hand swab

25

5(20)

(Megersa 2015)

2014/15

Oromia

Ambo and Guder

Udder swab

135

21(15.6)

  1. N sample size, n number of positive, p prevalence, SNNPR South Nations Nationalities and Peoples Region, MCC Milk collection center